Which Sweeteners Are Actually Fine, and Which I Would Avoid
By Tina Chagoury, Clinical Dietitian · 5 min read · 2026-11-16
If you want sweetness without sugar, there are better and worse options, and the reasoning is not complicated.
If you want sweetness without the sugar, some options are genuinely fine and some I would avoid. Here is my reasoning on each.
The ones I avoid
Aspartame and sucralose. These are the artificial sweeteners I do not recommend. There are ongoing questions in the research about their effects, including on the gut microbiome, and I do not consider them desirable at all.
I would rather someone had a small amount of real sugar occasionally than a daily habit of these.
Diet soda. This appears on the list of the biggest inflammatory triggers I remove in the second week of any protocol, alongside crisps and daily deliveries.
The ones I am comfortable with
Stevia. My usual first choice, for a straightforward reason: its taste is less aggressive than monk fruit. That matters more than it sounds, because a sweetener you find unpleasant is one you will abandon.
Monk fruit. Fine, and genuinely useful for many people. Some find the aftertaste strong.
Allulose. Also acceptable, and it behaves more like sugar in cooking, which makes it practical.
None of these carry meaningful calories or produce a significant blood sugar response, which is the whole point.
Honey and dates
These come up constantly, and my answer is more nuanced.
Between honey and dates for sweetening, I would choose honey, because it contains prebiotic compounds that are slightly better for the gut.
But I want to be clear about what honey is. It is sugar. It is a more interesting sugar with some additional compounds, and it is still sugar, and it still produces a glucose response.
The same applies to dates, and to maple syrup, and to coconut sugar. Natural does not mean it behaves differently in your bloodstream.
If you are managing insulin resistance or working seriously on blood sugar stability, treat these as sugar, because that is what they are.
The point that matters more than the list
The sweetener is rarely the problem.
Processed sugar is an inflammatory trigger of the first order, and the issue is the pattern: consumed in excess, whenever you want, in whatever quantity you want. Glucose rises and falls, rises and falls, every day, for weeks and months and years.
That instability is one of the leading drivers of inflammation in the body. And chronic inflammation is one of the largest contributors to long term disease risk.
Swapping the sweetener while leaving that pattern intact changes very little.
What I would actually do
Reduce the overall desire for sweetness rather than optimising the substitute. This happens naturally when blood sugar stabilises. Protein within the first hour of waking, protein at every meal, three structured meals and no grazing. The afternoon pull toward sugar fades within about two weeks for most women.
When you do want something sweet, have it after a meal rather than alone. Dark chocolate is a good example. It contains antioxidants, it is anti inflammatory in small quantities, and eaten after food it produces a far smaller glucose response than eaten on its own.
Use stevia, monk fruit or allulose when you want sweetness without sugar.
Do not build a diet around replacements. A cupboard full of engineered substitutes is usually a sign the underlying pattern has not been addressed.
This article is nutrition education, not medical advice.
Tina Chagoury is a licensed clinical dietitian specialising in women's hormonal health, and the creator of the Hormone Reset Methodâ„¢. Learn more and start here.
Related reading
Work with Tina Chagoury
Tina Chagoury is a clinical dietitian and the creator of the Hormone Reset Methodâ„¢, a structured programme for women whose hormones, energy, weight and cycles have stopped behaving the way they used to. Learn more about the Hormone Reset Method and start here. About Tina Chagoury.